Extra-Mature Cheddar & Mustard Potato Traybake with Leeks

Shared recipe · British

Extra-Mature Cheddar & Mustard Potato Traybake with Leeks

Serves 4 · 2 hr 5 min total

A proper British comfort traybake of golden roast potatoes and buttery leeks under a thick blanket of mustardy Co-op mash and a bronzed Cathedral City Extra Mature Cheddar crust.

Ingredients

Mash topping

  • 2 tbspEnglish mustard
  • 350 gExtra mature Cheddar
  • 400 gMashed potato
  • 4 tbspwhole milk

Tray

  • 1 kgWhite potatoes
  • 1brown onion
  • 10 gfresh thyme leaves
  • 3garlic cloves
  • 500 gleeks
  • 4 tbspolive oil
  • 30 gunsalted butter

Seasoning

  • 1 tspblack pepper
  • 1.5 tspfine salt

To serve

  • 1lemons (zest) (optional)

Method

  1. 1Heat the oven to 200°C (180°C fan). Scrub the potatoes, cut into 3cm chunks and pat dry. Tip into a large roasting tin with 3 tbsp olive oil, half the thyme leaves, 1 tsp salt and plenty of black pepper; toss well and roast for 35 minutes until the edges are starting to colour.
  2. 2Meanwhile, trim and thickly slice the leeks, rinse well and drain. Peel and slice the onion. Melt the butter with 1 tbsp olive oil in a large non-stick frying pan over medium heat, add the leeks, onion and a pinch of salt, and cook 12–15 minutes until soft and sweet but not browned.
  3. 3Crush the garlic into the pan for the last 2 minutes, then stir in the English mustard and remaining thyme. Taste and adjust salt and pepper; take off the heat.
  4. 4Coarsely grate all of the Cathedral City Extra Mature Cheddar. Tip the Co-op Mashed Potato into a bowl, loosen with the milk, then beat in one-third of the grated cheddar and a good grind of black pepper until smooth and spoonable.
  5. 5When the potatoes have had 35 minutes, pull the tin out and scatter the soft leek mixture evenly over them. Spoon the mustardy mash over the top in big dollops and spread gently to the edges so the veg are covered.
  6. 6Blanket the surface with the remaining grated cheddar. Return the tin to the oven for 30–35 minutes until the cheese is deep golden, bubbling at the edges and the potatoes underneath are tender when pierced.
  7. 7Rest the traybake 5–8 minutes so the mash settles. Finish with a twist of black pepper and the lemon zest if using, then spoon straight from the tin.
  8. 8Taste at the table and add a little extra salt or a dab of mustard on the side if you want more punch.